Monthly Archives: March 2013

The Sin of Being a Hazara

Editor’s Note: This story was originally published as a Cover Story in March issue of Newsline Magazine.


Brain drain from Balochistan: Story of Ali Raza – a Hazara engineer who was hounded out of Pakistan


Ali Raza, second left, discussing Hazara killings with Norwegian MPs.

Ali Raza, like most youth of his community, grew up in Quetta with ambitions of becoming a ‘big man’ and serving his people and country. Despite facing countless hardships, he had finally made it. He was now an engineer – a prestigious profession in Pakistan’s largest but most underdeveloped and poverty-striken province, Balochistan.

Raza, a Shia from Hazara, had no idea that his home province would be overrun by terrorism, militancy, discrimination and hatred. He was probably unaware that the thousands of religious seminaries that were mushrooming across the province were tasked to produce hundreds of non-state actors who could be used in clean-up operations against anybody labelled as ‘impure’ by their external and internal sponsors.

Raza’s first job was as a systems engineer, at the regional office of the National Database & Registration Authority (NADRA) in Mashkay in Balochistan’s Awaran district. He joined in August 2005, and only a couple of months later received a letter saying, ‘Shias are infidels and deserve to be killed.’

“I used to ignore such leaflets but one day a couple of armed and masked men broken into the NADRA office looking for me. I had just returned from my vacations and was luckily at a friend’s house that day.” Raza quit his job out of fear.

Subsequently, in 2006, he joined the Balochistan University of Engineering and Technology, Khuzdar, as a lecturer but he was not made to feel welcome. “I faced prejudice even from the university administration. They used to call me ‘settler bhai’ – a term otherwise used for outsiders,” he explained bitterly. “I was not allotted a room at the teacher’s hostel at the university for nearly a month. Later, I had to leave the university when I found myself on a hospital bed after being hit on the head one morning just as I emerged from my room.”

Disappointed with government offices, he chose Alcatel-Lucent, a global telecommunications equipment company. Things ran smoothly, but this was short-lived. Soon Raza started receiving ‘death threats’ at his office located in New Al-Gilani Street, Zarghoon Road, Quetta. “Don’t come to the office if you want to live,” the letters read. “We were three Hazara engineers employed there,” says Raza. “I avoided going to office afterwards and used to go directly to the working sites from home.”

That didn’t solve the problem, and Raza eventually resigned in October following “threatening phone calls.”

Fed up of the discrimination and hostility, Raza decided to leave Pakistan for Norway and stay there until the situation at home improved. Meanwhile, he enrolled for an MSc degree in ICT (Information & Communication Technology) from the University of Agder.

But the law and order situation in Balochistan did not improve. Rather it continued to deteriorate day-by-day and reached its peak in 2012, which was the deadline set by the banned militant outfit Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (LeJ) for the Hazara Shias to leave Pakistan in threatening letters distributed in Quetta.

According to a report published by the Norwegian Peace-Building Resource Center (NOREF), “the surge in LeJ violence against Hazaras is related to the growing presence of Afghan and Pakistani Taliban militants in Balochistan: the extremist Sunni Taliban have historically been anti-Shia and anti-Hazara, and their financial and operational links with LeJ have bolstered sectarian violence in the province… As such, the sectarian violence in Balochistan has an ethnic dimension.”

And the onslaught continues. Around 115 innocent lives were lost in about 60 targeted attacks in 2012 and nearly 200 have been killed this year in two separate bomb blasts. The government of Balochistan and the law enforcement agencies remain mere spectators, leading to a feeling of hopelessness and despair among the Hazaras of Balochistan. Most of the low-level government employees belonging to the Hazara community have either quit their jobs or taken long leave in order to avert any further attacks.


Hazara Graveyard, Mehrabad.

Many traders, businessmen and shopkeepers have sold their properties at throwaway prices. Then there are those who have temporarily shut down their businesses and are waiting for the situation to improve. Their movements have been strictly restricted to their own enclaves.

The discrimination against this ethno-sectarian minority was also noted in a report of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) released last August that said: “The administration seems to bear ethnic and sectarian biases against the Hazara-Shia community. Since the new government assumed charge, not a single challan (charge sheet) had been presented in courts against the accused. The accused are arrested in the morning and released in the afternoon. No government or public official had ever condemned the targeted killing of members of the Hazara community nor come to condole the murders or offer any compensation to the victims’ families.”

Recently the daily Dawn carried a report about the photographs of Hazara police martyrs being torn to shreds inside the government building and the name plates outside the offices of Hazara police officers being broken, which indicates the extent of hatred against the community.

Ali Raza is not the only Hazara Shia professional to be hounded out of Pakistan. He is just one example of this enforced brain-drain, which has not only caused irreparable damage to the community, but also to the instability-struck province as a whole.

Will Raza forget his unpleasant past? “No, not at all. It is impossible to disconnect yourself from your homeland, from your people and from your childhood place. Isn’t it?” he replied.

He has played an active role in organising protest rallies against the ‘genocide’ of his people in front of the Norwegian parliament. He led the Hazara delegation in a meeting with Norwegian politicians, Mrs Marit Nybakk of the Labour Party and MP Akhtar Chaudhry of the Socialist Party, in the Parliament House in Oslo and asked them to put pressure on the government of Pakistan to protect his community.

Raza himself has lost two of his cousins to terrorism. His wife’s only brother was killed in 2004, but he is unwilling to give up his fight against terrorism in Pakistan, in spite of the continuing threats.

“My family still lives in Pakistan. I miss my two-and-a half-year old child very much. I see him via Skype. But this is not enough for a father to express his love,” he says emotionally. “Nowadays being a Hazara is a crime in Pakistan.”

Raza’s fears proved true. Just when I was done with this interview, twin blasts killed 106 people on Alamdar Road, a Hazara dominated area of Quetta. This time the Hazara community refused to burry the dead bodies. ‘there is no more space in the graveyard’, said Ejaz Hussain, an attandant of the sit-in protest.

There was a almost a complete media-blackout, as usual, for the first day of the sit-in protest which was attended by thousands of people including women and children, but the social-media had informed that people across Pakistan who took to the streets to express solidarity with the protesters in Quetta which forced the media proper to report the incident. Protest rallies were held across the world, including Norway, where Raza and his co-activists staged candel-light vigils in front of Noweigian parliament in Oslo which was attendent by the country’s activists and politicians.

Protest demonstrations continued across the globe, from Canada to Australia and Mongolia et el, even after removal of Nawab Aslam Raisani’s governemnt and imposition of Governer’s rule in Balochistan.

“None has been captured for all these massacres, despite video-tapes being available [reffering to videos of Mastung and Akhtarabad massacre where Hazara men were taken off the bus and slaughtered] and those responsible being known to the Pakistani authorities.” Said Reza Javid, one of the organizers of a protest rally in front of Swedish parliament in Stockholm on January 18. “Those responsible for the genocide of Hazaras have to be arrested and tried in the court of law and only then we can trust the Pakistani authorities who had previously also promised to provide security to the community, but all proved false”.

Removal of the provinncial governemnt was more of a morale victory for the protersters but the sense of insecurity still exists among the members of the community who remain restricted to their own specific localities. “Targeted operations against the terrorists’ known camps and areas”, in Javid’s words, “was the actual demand which hast yet to be met.”

Over a hundred died, among them women and children, more than 200 sustained serious injuries when a powerful bombed ripped through a busy vegetable market in Hazara Town on 16th February 2013. This time the Governor of Balochistan, Nawab Zulfiqar Ali Magsi, openly blamed the intelligence and security forces for the failure to prevent the attack.

The onslaught against the ethno-sectarian minority may resume unless the terror networks are dismantled. Around 50,000 Hazaras have left Pakistan over last one decade. Ali Raza is an example of the enforced brain-drain which has not only created an unrepairable damage to the community but to the entire instability-struck province.

Dr.Saleem Javed is freelance journalist and human rights activist from Quetta. He tweets at @mSaleemJaved and can be reached at dr.saleemjavid[at]

Editor’s Note: This story was originally published as a Cover Story in March issue of Newsline Magazine.

Categories: Pakistan | 1 Comment

Searching for protection

This discussion was aired on Al-Jazeera English after rumors of Hazara youths picking up arms to defend themselves as the government and security forces had blatantly failed to protect them from the Al-Qaeda linked terrorists outfits.


For viewers in countries where Youtube is banned:

Is Pakistan’s government unable to provide security for its own citizens? Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, a banned Pakistani militant group, continues to target the Shia community in Balochistan province. After three deadly bombings this year claimed hundreds of lives, members of Pakistan’s Shia minority are taking up arms to defend themselves. We examine the ongoing violence against the country’s Shia community.

In this episode of The Stream, we speak to:

Mohammad Taqi @mazdaki
Columnist, Daily Times

Major Nadir Ali
Senior leader of Hazara tribe in Pakistan

Syed Ali Abbas Zaidi @Ali_Abbas_Zaidi
Pakistan Youth Alliance

Saleem Javid @msaleemjaved
Human rights activist

Sajjad Changezi @sajjad_changezi

Shehroz Hussain @shehrozhussain

Categories: In The Media | Tags: , , , , | 1 Comment

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: